Tires
All-Season vs All-Weather vs Winter Tires: An Ottawa Guide
All-season tires are not winter tires: they don't carry the winter symbol, and the Ontario government says they can start to lose grip at 7°C. All-weather tires do carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol and can stay on all year, which suits many drivers who mostly use cleared city roads. Dedicated winter tires give the most grip on ice and in deep cold, and they're the better choice if you commute on the highway in every kind of weather.
All-season vs all-weather vs winter tires at a glance
- All-season tires: built for spring, summer and fall. No snowflake symbol. The rubber hardens as temperatures drop, so grip fades in an Ottawa winter.
- All-weather tires: a year-round tire that carries the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol. One set, no seasonal swap, but a compromise in both deep winter and summer heat.
- Winter tires: a dedicated cold-weather tire with the snowflake symbol, soft rubber and an aggressive tread. The best winter grip, but you need a second set for the warm months.
What the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol means
The symbol shows a mountain with three peaks and a snowflake inside. A tire can carry it only after passing a regulated traction test on medium-packed snow, where it has to beat a standard reference tire by a set margin. That's why CAA calls it the sign of a tire that has passed a government-regulated traction test. An "M+S" (mud and snow) marking on its own is not the same thing; those tires are not winter tires.
The symbol has one important limit. It measures traction in snow. Transport Canada notes there is no minimum government standard for winter tire performance on ice in Canada. Two tires with the same symbol can behave quite differently on a glare-ice morning, and that's where all-weather and winter tires part ways.
All-season vs all-weather tires
All-season tire rubber starts to harden at around 7°C, which costs traction and grip. In Ottawa, the average daytime high has already dropped to about 5°C by November and stays below 7°C right through March, based on Environment Canada climate normals for the airport. For roughly five months a year, an all-season tire is working outside the range it was designed for.
An all-weather tire is designed to handle that cold and carries the snowflake symbol, so it legally counts as a winter tire where one is required. The trade-off runs both ways. CAA-Quebec, which calls them winter-approved all-season tires, says their tread compound is harder than a winter tire's and their tread pattern less aggressive, so braking distances are longer, especially on ice. In summer, they also lose some efficiency compared with a regular all-season or summer tire.
All-weather vs winter tires
Winter tires use rubber designed to stay flexible in the cold, which gives better traction in snow, slush and ice and on cold, dry pavement. According to the Ontario government, winter tires improve traction and control in frost, snow and icy conditions and can shorten braking distances by as much as 25%.
The cost is practical: two sets of tires, a changeover each fall and spring, and somewhere to keep the off-season set. Winter tires also wear faster if you leave them on into warm weather, so they should come off in spring.
Winter tires or all-weather tires: which suits your Ottawa driving
Highway commuters from Kanata and Orléans
If you drive the Queensway from Kanata or the 174 from Orléans into the core every weekday, you're on the road early, at highway speed, often before the plows have finished, and you can't choose to stay home when it storms. Ottawa also sees freezing rain or freezing drizzle on about 16 days a year on average. That combination of speed, ice and no flexibility is where dedicated winter tires earn their keep.
In-town drivers in Nepean and central Ottawa
If most of your driving is shorter trips around Nepean or the central neighbourhoods, on plowed and salted streets at lower speeds, and you can wait out the worst mornings, a good all-weather tire is a reasonable choice. You get a tire that meets the winter standard without the twice-yearly swap.
A few other things to weigh
- All-wheel drive helps you get moving, but it doesn't help you stop or steer on ice. Tires do that.
- Studded tires aren't an option for most Ottawa drivers. Ontario allows them on vehicles registered in Northern Ontario, but not in Southern Ontario unless you're visiting from out of province.
Winter tires in Ontario: the insurance discount
Ontario doesn't require winter tires, but it does reward them. Under Ontario's auto insurance regulations, insurers must offer a discount on private passenger vehicle policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2016, when the car is equipped with winter tires. Each insurer sets the size of the discount, the dates the tires must be on, and what proof it needs. If you're switching to all-weather tires, ask your insurer whether tires with the snowflake symbol qualify for its discount, since policies vary.
Driving into Gatineau: Quebec's winter tire law
Quebec requires winter tires from December 1 to March 15 on motor vehicles registered in Quebec, including rental cars. To count, a tire must carry the snowflake pictogram or be studded, and an all-weather tire with the symbol meets the rule. The fine for non-compliance is $200 to $300.
The law doesn't apply to vehicles registered outside Quebec, so an Ontario-plated car crossing the bridges to Gatineau isn't breaking the rule on all-season tires. The roads on the other side get the same winter, though, and almost every Quebec car around you will be on winter-rated tires. If you move to Gatineau and register your car in Quebec, the rule applies to you.
When to put on winter tires in Ottawa
CAA's rule of thumb is to switch when daytime temperatures fall below 7°C, or when you can see your breath outside, rather than waiting for the first snowfall. Going by Ottawa's average temperatures, that point usually arrives in early November. Our guide on when to put on winter tires in Ottawa covers timing in more detail, and tire tread depth and age explains how to tell whether last year's set is still up to the job.
Get the right tires at Janex
The Janex Automotive service department at 1138 Carling Ave in Ottawa handles tire service and can help you match all-weather or winter tires to how you actually drive. Book online and a service advisor will call to confirm your time, or call 613-686-5577, Monday to Friday, 8:30AM to 5:30PM.